Frag-Einen

Ask a lawyer on the topic of Other questions to lawyers

Electricity supplier Right of way New Federal States

Good day,

It applies: New federal states - Saxony. Rights of way of the energy providers not yet registered in the land register. I refer to the following article:

www.bbt-group.de/fileadmin/content/pdf/DW_10_2009.pdf

In addition, there is a disagreement with the energy provider regarding certain responsibilities.

So:
Two years ago we bought a property in Saxony with a residential house and forest area of ​​approximately 17 hectares. Now, at the end of this year - so December, January - there should be a first thinning of a smaller part of the forest of approximately 2 hectares in size, through which a low-voltage line runs that supplies our house and three other houses (our house is the first in this "chain" that is supplied with electricity through this line). The other houses are no longer on our property.

Together with our forest ranger, we have already tried to persuade the energy provider, as the owner of this line, to remove the cable, which is essential when using modern timber harvesting machines. However, the energy provider is only willing to disconnect the line. He would not be responsible for laying it down, but could hire an external company for a fee of around 100 euros per day. Allegedly, there are fixed cost rates for such measures.

We find this demand quite unreasonable, as the energy provider uses our property for his line, which also supplies other people with electricity. After all, this prevents us from using the forest land for some square meters (under the line plus protection strip)!

Are we really powerless and without any right to claims just because we ALSO receive electricity from this line? It is a kind of T-shaped branch, so the line has an extra branch to the house and otherwise continues to other properties. About 200m but still on our land.

In summary: Do we really have to pay for laying down the line? What about compensation for the line through our property according to Section 9 GBBerG?

(We thought of a small "deal" with the energy provider: Free removal of the line in exchange for waiving compensation according to Section 9 GBBerG...

After inquiry at the land registry office, no easements for the energy provider are registered for the property yet, but the local employee said that the energy providers are currently strongly pushing for this (legal deadline until the end of 2010). The length of the line on our property is estimated at 200-250 meters, of which an estimated 50-80 meters are exclusively supply line to our house. The house has been standing for about 80 years, just like the other three houses supplied by the line, so the line itself must be at least 50 years old. This should be relevant for the provisions in Section 9 GBBerG.

We are currently considering whether it would be helpful and promising to persuade the energy provider to lay down the line for free in exchange for

Dr. Dr. Danjel-Philippe Newerla

Dear inquirer,

Thank you for your inquiry!

Taking into account the information you provided, I would like to answer the questions you asked as follows:

Regarding 1.) Do we really have to pay for laying the line?

Thank you for the very interesting article that, in my opinion, pertains directly to your situation and will be further discussed under point two.

You wouldn't have to pay if you could assert a claim for injunction against the energy provider pursuant to § 1004 of the Civil Code. However, this would require that the disruption caused by the energy provider is unlawful or cannot be tolerated by you. In the present case, however, as you can see from the article you kindly attached, this is not the situation.

According to the Grundbuchbereinigungsgesetz, the provider has the right to register an easement in Section 2 of the relevant land register until the end of 2010, without even needing your approval.

To put it differently, the energy provider can choose not to assert this right and remove their line, but the negotiation of the costs for removing the line would be a matter of discussion.

Regarding 2.) What about compensation for the line crossing our property under Paragraph 9 GBBerG? (We were thinking of a small "deal" with the energy provider: Free removal of the line in exchange for waiving compensation under Paragraph 9 GBBerG)

Your proposal to waive compensation in exchange for the removal of the line is very reasonable and clever, as it provides you with some leverage. Based on the facts you provided, the requirements of § 9 GBBerG are met, so you are entitled to fair compensation. As for the valuation, I can only refer you to the second page of the article you attached, which discusses this point in detail. If necessary, an appraiser would need to determine the exact value of the compensation.

I hope my explanations have been helpful to you. Feel free to contact me through the follow-up option on this platform or via my email address.

I would like to emphasize the following: The legal advice I have given is based solely on the information provided by you. My response is only a preliminary legal assessment of the situation and cannot replace a comprehensive examination of the facts. Adding or omitting relevant information can lead to a completely different legal assessment.

Wishing you a pleasant Wednesday afternoon!

Best regards,

Dipl.-Jur. Danjel-Philippe Newerla, Attorney

Heilsbergerstr. 16
27580 Bremerhaven
kanzlei.newerla@web.de
Tel. 0471/3088132
Fax. 0471/57774

fadeout
... Are you also interested in this question?
You can view the complete answer for only 7,50 EUR.

Experte für Other questions to lawyers

Dr. Dr. Danjel-Philippe Newerla

Dr. Dr. Danjel-Philippe Newerla

Bremerhaven

Amtsgerichtsbezirk: Bremerhaven

Berufshaftpflichtversicherung:

R+V Versicherung AG
Taunusstr.1
65193 Wiesbaden



Die Rechtsanwaltskanzlei Newerla beschäftigt sich schwerpunktmäßig mit dem Familien-, dem Erb-, dem Wettbewerbs-, Internet- und Computerrecht sowie dem allgemeinen Zivilrecht.

Neben der klassischen
Rechtsberatung und der außergerichtlichen sowie gerichtlichen Vertretung hat sich die Kanzlei auf die Erstellung sowie Überprüfung von Verträgen jeglicher Art, sowie Allgemeinen Geschäftsbedingungen und Onlineauftritten sowie die Abwehr wettbewerbsrechtlicher, sowie marken- und urheberrechtlicher Abmahnungen spezialisiert.

Expert knowledge:
  • Media law
  • Internet and computer law
Complete profile